Controversy Erupts Over Dukes Cricket Ball in India-England Test Series

Concerns Raised About Ball Quality

The ongoing Test series between India and England has sparked a significant debate, not over tactics or umpiring, but regarding the performance of the Dukes cricket ball used throughout the five-match series.

Following the Edgbaston Test, Indian captain Shubman Gill voiced his frustrations, stating that the ball was losing its shape and becoming soft too quickly, which hindered bowlers' ability to take wickets.

Gill remarked, 'The bowlers are facing challenges. The ball is the main issue, losing its shape prematurely and softening too fast. I’m not sure if it’s the pitch or something else, but it’s certainly complicating wicket-taking in these conditions.'

Rishabh Pant Supports Gill's Claims

Ahead of the third Test at Lord's, vice-captain Rishabh Pant echoed Gill's sentiments during a pre-match press conference, labeling the condition of the ball as a 'significant problem.'

'It’s definitely an issue. The ball keeps losing its shape. If you look closely, it’s not even spherical anymore—it resembles a 'D.' But this is the rule we have to abide by unless someone decides to change it,' Pant stated.

Dukes Manufacturer Defends Ball Quality

In response to the criticism, Dilip Jagjodia, the producer of the Dukes balls, defended their quality, explaining the inherent variations in handmade products.

Speaking to a media outlet, Jagjodia said, 'Cricket balls, whether Dukes, SG, or Kookaburra, often attract attention. However, we must remember these are handmade items crafted from natural materials. No manufacturer can guarantee uniformity or perfection.'

He also pointed out that modern bats and stronger players contribute to the issue. 'Bats have become incredibly powerful. Take Shubman Gill, for instance—he’s not typically a six-hitter, yet he’s hitting sixes effortlessly. These balls are being struck into stands and structures, which will inevitably affect their shape.'

The Natural Softening of Test Balls

Regarding the ball softening too soon, Jagjodia was firm in his stance. 'A Test ball is expected to soften over time, which is why there’s a rule for a new ball after 80 overs. However, there seems to be a lack of patience. If bowlers aren’t taking wickets by 30 or 40 overs, they want a replacement, hoping for something firmer.'

He emphasized that despite the complaints, the ball has not hindered match outcomes. 'This series has seen competitive contests, with high scores and all wickets taken. India managed to bowl out England twice in the last match—the ball is clearly fulfilling its role.'

Ongoing Debate in the Series

With both team captains expressing their concerns and the manufacturer standing by the product, the debate surrounding the Dukes ball is likely to persist as the series progresses. Whether this controversy will lead to any changes remains uncertain, but it is clear that players are not fully satisfied with the current situation.