The Distinction Between a Doctor and a Good Doctor: Insights from Dr. Janak Raj

Reflections on Medical Practice

Mahindra Patyal
Bharmaur

Dr. Janak Raj, a distinguished neurosurgeon and former senior official at IGMC Shimla, has recently shared his thoughts following a significant incident at the institution. He highlighted the critical difference between merely being a doctor and embodying the qualities of a good doctor.

Dr. Raj articulated, “A doctor focuses solely on the illness. He diagnoses, prescribes treatment, and moves on. To him, the patient is just a case—a number, a file. His demeanor is often cold, his gaze fixed on the clock, and his words rushed. While he may possess the necessary skills, his care only addresses the physical body, leaving the emotional aspect untouched. Patients may leave with medication but often feel a void within.”

Conversely, a good doctor perceives the patient as a whole person. He recognizes the pain reflected in their expressions, acknowledges the fear in their eyes, and offers comfort by holding their hand, saying, “Don’t worry, I am here for you. Everything will be alright.” He addresses patients by name, listens attentively, and communicates with kindness. His tone conveys empathy, and his actions demonstrate respect. He understands that alongside medical treatment, instilling hope is a vital part of healing.

Dr. Raj emphasized that hospitals should not be viewed merely as physical structures but as sanctuaries for those in distress, where every tear should be wiped away and every fear acknowledged. “Every word spoken in a hospital can either mend a wound or inflict a new one,” he remarked.

He pointed out that today’s informed society expects not just advanced technology and medications but also compassionate care and respectful communication. True healing, he insisted, cannot be achieved unless healthcare professionals extend compassion to each other and to their patients.

“Let us work together to transform hospitals into places where individuals feel not only treated but also valued, reassured, and secure. Ultimately, healing encompasses not just the body but also the mind, and it is humanity and compassion that serve as the true medicine.”