Supreme Court's Decision on Chief Election Commissioner Law Sparks Debate
Supreme Court Addresses Recall Plea
New Delhi: On Friday, the Supreme Court rejected a request to separately address a plea aimed at recalling a split verdict from a two-judge panel regarding the referral of challenges to the 2023 law that governs the appointment of the Chief Election Commissioner (CEC) and Election Commissioners (ECs) to a larger bench.
The bench, led by Chief Justice of India (CJI) Surya Kant along with Justices Joymalya Bagchi and V Mohana, stated that both the recall application and any challenges to the reference order could be evaluated by the five-judge Constitution bench already set up to review the petitions questioning the legitimacy of the Chief Election Commissioner and Other Election Commissioners (Appointment, Conditions of Service and Term of Office) Act, 2023.
CJI Kant indicated that the five-judge bench could still consider the recall application even if one of the judges involved in the split verdict retires.
Advocate Bhushan argued that the recall plea should be presented before the original bench, which included Justices Dipankar Datta and Satish Chandra Sharma, who issued the split verdict on September 23.
He highlighted that Justice Sharma was set to retire the following week and claimed a conflict of interest, suggesting that the recall application should be reviewed by the same bench.
In response to the CJI's suggestion that the reference bench could handle the application, Bhushan noted that the reference order itself was previously recalled due to an alleged conflict of interest.
However, the CJI maintained that the matter could be brought before the five-judge Constitution bench, which is tasked with the final decision on the constitutional challenge to the 2023 law.
This situation arises after the split verdict delivered on September 23 by Justices Datta and Sharma, which addressed whether the petitions against the 2023 law should be considered by a larger bench.
The primary concern raised was the exclusion of the CJI from the selection panel for the CEC and ECs, which now consists of the prime minister, the leader of the opposition in the Lok Sabha, and a cabinet minister.
Justice Datta believed that the challenge could be resolved by a two-judge bench, while Justice Sharma advocated for a referral to a five-judge Constitution bench due to the significant constitutional issues at stake.
