Supreme Court Seeks Responses on NRC Reverification Petition from Assam and Central Governments

The Supreme Court has directed the Centre and Assam government to respond to a petition from the All Assam Students’ Union (AASU) regarding the reverification of the National Register of Citizens (NRC). The AASU claims that the 2019 NRC update process was flawed, with only 19 lakh individuals excluded, raising doubts about its credibility. This issue has reignited discussions on illegal immigration in Assam, with the AASU demanding a comprehensive review of the NRC and electoral rolls. The organization argues that the presence of illegal immigrants in the electoral rolls remains a concern, calling for a Special Intensive Revision to ensure the integrity of the voter list.
 | 
gyanhigyan

Supreme Court's Notice on NRC Reverification

File image of the Supreme Court of India. (Photo: X)


New Delhi, Nov 18: On Tuesday, the Supreme Court directed the Centre and the Assam government to respond to a petition from the All Assam Students’ Union (AASU). The petition calls for a reexamination of the National Register of Citizens (NRC) published in Assam in 2019, citing significant discrepancies in the update process and the inclusion of names of suspected illegal Bangladeshi immigrants.


This development has reignited the contentious debate surrounding the identification of illegal immigrants in Assam. The prominent student organization argues that the final NRC did not adequately address the issues that fueled the prolonged Assam Movement against illegal migration.


The case was presented before a two-judge bench, consisting of Justice Pamidighantam Sri Narasimha and Justice Alok Aradhe, who issued notices to both the Centre and the State government after reviewing AASU’s petition.


In response, AASU chief advisor Samujjal Bhattacharya expressed to the media that the organization is seeking a thorough review of the entire NRC update process. He pointed out that the exclusion of only about 19 lakh individuals from the final register raises serious doubts about its reliability.


“When the NRC was released in 2019, only 19 lakh names were omitted, which casts doubt on the entire process. We have filed a petition for reverification to ensure that Assam has an NRC devoid of illegal Bangladeshi immigrants. The Supreme Court has accepted our petition for hearing and has requested responses from the Central and State governments,” Bhattacharya stated.


AASU president Utpal Sarma, who represented the organization alongside Bhattacharya in court, mentioned that the petition calls for a comprehensive reassessment of the NRC update process, considering Assam's unique historical context regarding migration issues.


“Assam is the most affected state in the country concerning illegal immigration. This is why the NRC concept was primarily relevant to Assam. A significant effort was made to update the 1951 NRC. However, when the register was published in 2019, only 19 lakh individuals were excluded. The people of Assam and AASU anticipated a much higher number of foreigners in the State,” Sarma explained.


He also referenced a statement made in Parliament in 2005 by then Union Home Minister Prakash Jaiswal, which claimed that nearly 50 lakh Bangladeshis were living in Assam. AASU has used such estimates to challenge the results of the NRC exercise.


The student organization has reiterated its demand for a Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls in Assam, arguing that the identification of suspected illegal immigrants should extend beyond the NRC process and be reflected in the electoral verification process as well.


Bhattacharya noted that the Assam Movement, which began in 1979, was initiated due to concerns over the presence of alleged illegal foreigners in the electoral rolls during the Mangaldoi Lok Sabha byelection.


“The Assam Agitation started over the inclusion of illegal Bangladeshi names in the voters’ list. Even now, we do not believe that Assam has a voter list free from Bangladeshis. We demand a Special Intensive Revision of the electoral rolls,” he asserted.


He further emphasized that the issuance of identity documents should be suspended until a revised NRC, free from the names of illegal Bangladeshi immigrants, is published.


The call for an intensive revision of electoral rolls is particularly significant as the Assam election department recently released the draft electoral rolls under the Special Summary Revision (SSR) 2027, following the Election Commission's decision last year to conduct a special revision exercise in the State.


The NRC, initially compiled in 1951, was updated under the Supreme Court's supervision, with the final list published on August 31, 2019. This exercise aimed to identify Indian citizens in Assam according to the relevant legal framework.


The final register excluded around 19 lakh applicants, sparking widespread debate over the results and subsequent calls for its acceptance and implementation.