Supreme Court Inquiry into Alleged Fake Police Encounters in Assam Stalled

The Supreme Court's inquiry into 171 alleged fake police encounters in Assam is facing significant delays due to a lack of leadership within the Assam Human Rights Commission. With key positions unfilled, questions arise about accountability for police actions. The inquiry, which follows a directive from the Supreme Court, aims to address serious concerns regarding human rights violations. Meanwhile, state data reveals over 190 encounters involving individuals already in custody, highlighting ongoing issues within law enforcement practices. As families await answers, the urgency for a resolution grows.
 | 
gyanhigyan

Supreme Court's Inquiry Faces Challenges

File image of the Supreme Court of India. (Photo: X)


GUWAHATI, Nov 16: The Supreme Court's investigation into 171 suspected fake police encounters in Assam has yet to progress, raising concerns amid ongoing scrutiny of police encounter deaths.


The Assam Human Rights Commission (AHRC), tasked by the Supreme Court to carry out a thorough and prompt investigation, is currently hindered by a lack of leadership, as it operates without its chairman and one of its two members.


This situation has led to questions about accountability for the police, especially when the body responsible for probing alleged human rights abuses is facing a shortage of personnel.


In May 2025, the Supreme Court instructed the Commission to investigate the 171 alleged fake encounters that occurred between May 2021 and August 2022. Following this directive, the AHRC issued nearly 1,000 notices to police officers involved in the cases where the accused were reportedly shot while in custody.


Justice (retired) Arup Goswami, the AHRC chairman, stepped down in July 2026, and the term of commission member Santanu Barthakur ended in April 2026. The State Home Department has not appointed replacements or extended their tenures, leaving the Commission without key leadership.


“The lack of personnel raises significant concerns about the government's dedication to ensuring accountability in cases of alleged human rights violations by law enforcement. An inquiry involving numerous police officers and multiple alleged encounter deaths should not be stalled due to administrative delays,” remarked a human rights advocate.


From May 2021 to November 2026, state records indicate over 190 encounters involving individuals already in police custody, resulting in 42 fatalities and 149 injuries. These statistics are distinct from the 171 alleged fake encounters under the Supreme Court's inquiry.


While the 171 cases pertain specifically to alleged fake encounters reported between May 2021 and August 2022, the 190 encounters reflect incidents involving individuals in custody from May 2021 to November 2026.


The most recent death in police custody occurred on November 4, when Ghanakanta Gogoi, implicated in the October 26 Guwahati hotel shooting that resulted in five deaths, was shot dead in Sivasagar district. Authorities claimed he attempted to escape during transport.


Law enforcement has consistently asserted that officers resort to firing in self-defense when detainees attack or try to flee.


“For families seeking answers, promises and a Supreme Court directive will hold little weight unless the investigation concludes swiftly and effectively,” a source commented.