Steve Bucknor Reflects on Controversial LBW Decision Against Sachin Tendulkar

Bucknor's Regret Over a Notorious Decision

Steve Bucknor, the former West Indies umpire, has openly acknowledged that one of his most controversial decisions involving Sachin Tendulkar was indeed a mistake. Now at the age of 79, Bucknor reminisced about the infamous LBW call made during the Brisbane Test in the 2003-04 series, a moment that continues to resonate with Indian cricket enthusiasts.

Details of the Brisbane Test Incident

During the first innings of the match, Tendulkar attempted to evade a delivery from Jason Gillespie. The ball hit his pads, leading to a vociferous appeal from the Australian players. Bucknor, however, raised his finger, declaring Tendulkar out for a mere three runs. This decision shocked both fans and commentators, with Tony Greig famously labeling it as 'a dreadful decision' during the live broadcast.

Replays later revealed that the ball had pitched outside the off-stump and had swung back sharply, but its trajectory indicated it would have gone over the stumps. Tendulkar's stunned reaction on the field mirrored the disbelief of millions watching from home.

Bucknor's Acknowledgment of the Mistake

In a conversation with the West Indies Cricket Umpires' Association, Bucknor admitted to the blunder. He stated, 'Giving Sachin Tendulkar out leg before wicket was a mistake that people still discuss to this day.' He reflected on the decision, questioning, 'Why did I give him out? Was he out?' but ultimately accepted that mistakes are part of life.

His admission aligns with the long-held belief among fans that Tendulkar's dismissal at such a critical moment was unjust. This incident remains one of the most contentious umpiring decisions in cricket history, denying Tendulkar the opportunity to score significantly in a high-stakes series. Today, such decisions are often reviewed, minimizing the chances of similar controversies.