India's Strong Rejection of Turkiye's OIC Resolution: A Call for Inclusivity

India has voiced strong objections against Turkiye's exclusionary practices during the UN General Assembly discussions on a resolution concerning the Organisation of Islamic Cooperation (OIC). The resolution, which was adopted with significant support, faced opposition from India and several other nations due to concerns over transparency and inclusivity in the negotiation process. India's Deputy Permanent Representative at the UN, Yojna Patel, criticized the methods used by the resolution's facilitator and called for an investigation into the matter. The article delves into India's stance, the implications of the resolution, and the reactions from other nations, highlighting the ongoing challenges in international diplomacy.
 | 
gyanhigyan

India Voices Concerns at the UN General Assembly


United Nations/New Delhi: India has expressed strong disapproval regarding Turkiye's deliberate choice to exclude New Delhi and other nations from discussions on a resolution concerning collaboration between the UN and the Organisation of Islamic Cooperation (OIC). Consequently, India voted against the draft during the General Assembly session.


The resolution titled 'Cooperation between the United Nations and the Organisation of Islamic Cooperation', proposed by Iraq, was passed on Monday with 112 votes in favor, six against, and 39 abstentions.


India, alongside Armenia, Cyprus, Greece, Israel, and the United States, opposed the resolution, which was facilitated by Turkiye.


Countries like Cyprus and Greece also criticized Ankara for its 'lack of transparency and inclusivity' during the negotiation of the draft.


Yojna Patel, India's Deputy Permanent Representative at the UN, highlighted that the OIC's Permanent Observer Mission excluded the Indian delegation and several other nations when distributing successive drafts of the resolution.


In her explanation of the vote, Patel condemned the methods employed by the resolution's facilitator, labeling it a 'concerning matter' and calling for an inquiry into the process.


"My delegation has voted against this resolution not only due to its content but also because of the troubling methods used by the facilitator during negotiations," Patel stated.


She expressed her 'deep dismay' over the exclusion of her delegation and others, emphasizing that such actions are shocking and set a negative precedent for future negotiations.


Patel noted that despite objections from some delegations, the facilitators continued to exclude certain countries, disregarding basic procedures like acknowledging inputs, which seemed intentional rather than accidental.


She remarked that it is unfortunate that some member states, while publicly advocating for multilateralism, ignore its fundamental principles.


Patel reiterated that the UN was established on the ideals of sovereign equality, inclusivity, and multilateral cooperation, asserting that differences among member states should not justify the exclusion of any nation from discussions in the General Assembly.


"My delegation strongly objects to such practices that mislead excluded delegations into thinking this was merely a technical update, which it was not," she added.


India has urged the UN General Assembly President to investigate this matter and prevent similar occurrences in the future.


Questioning the resolution's substance, New Delhi pointed out that the draft claimed to address other conflicts, but the rationale for expanding the OIC's role remains unclear, as it is not a regional organization.


India also expressed concern over a reference in the resolution to the ninth session of the OIC Ministerial Conference on Women held in Islamabad in July, where a declaration was made that mentioned Jammu and Kashmir. Patel stated that India 'rejects' this declaration and the omnibus resolution from the conference.


"The resolution includes documents and statements that contain unwarranted and factually incorrect references to my country. These documents reflect the ongoing misuse of the OIC platform for narrow political purposes. The OIC has no right to comment on India's internal matters," Patel asserted.


In a subtle reference to Pakistan, India expressed regret that the OIC has once again been misused by one member state to weaponize OIC resolutions and declarations against India through unfounded allegations.


Pakistan is a founding and significant member of the 57-member OIC.


"India urges the OIC to adhere to the principles of objectivity, constructive dialogue, and mutual respect, ensuring that its outcomes do not serve narrow political agendas," Patel stated.


India believes that sovereign member states are responsible for safeguarding the interests of their citizens, regardless of their faith. Patel emphasized that the notion that only co-religionists can protect the interests of their faith's adherents is regressive and has no place in today's world, especially in this forum.


Cyprus, in its explanation of vote, expressed deep regret over Turkiye's lack of transparency and inclusivity as the facilitator throughout the negotiation process.


"We strongly regret that Cyprus has been repeatedly excluded from communications regarding this process and subsequently from the negotiation of this resolution. Inclusion of all UN Member States in this negotiation process is not a matter of political discretion for the facilitator, but a principle enshrined in the UN Charter," the Cyprus delegate stated.


Greece also raised 'serious concerns' about the negotiation conduct under Turkiye's facilitation.


"Throughout the process, the European Union submitted comments and amendments in good faith, which were neither adequately addressed nor accompanied by substantial explanations for their rejection. Additionally, revised drafts were circulated without sufficient consultation," the Greek delegate remarked.


Greece objected to its exclusion, along with certain delegations, from the circulation of draft texts, stating that such practices do not meet the transparency, inclusivity, and good faith expected in General Assembly negotiations.


The US expressed hope that future iterations of the OIC resolution would eliminate excessive and redundant language and contentious issues, focusing instead on direct and concrete areas of cooperation that can achieve consensus.


Ireland, speaking on behalf of the European Union, stated that the bloc and its member states regret the 'lack of transparency and inclusivity' throughout the negotiation process, despite requests for inclusion in consultations.


"The EU and several of its member states were excluded from relevant communications and were consequently not given a meaningful opportunity to participate in the negotiations," it concluded.