Controversies Surrounding the BCCI: A Historical Overview
Introduction to BCCI's Controversies
The Board of Control for Cricket in India (BCCI) has been embroiled in numerous controversies over the years, from the infamous match-fixing scandal of 2000 to the recent abandonment of a T20I match in Lucknow, raising significant governance concerns.
Major Scandals in BCCI's History
The BCCI is recognized as one of the most powerful cricket boards globally, backed by substantial financial resources and a significant administrative role. However, its history is marred by controversies that have drawn public scrutiny.
In 2000, the match-fixing scandal shook Indian cricket, leading to a loss of trust among fans. Revelations by former South African captain Hansie Cronje implicated Indian players, including former captain Mohammad Azharuddin and Ajay Jadeja, in accepting bribes to manipulate match outcomes. This scandal severely damaged the BCCI's reputation.
The Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) conducted an inquiry that resulted in life bans for Azharuddin and Ajay Sarma, while Jadeja received a five-year suspension. The BCCI took years to rebuild its credibility, implementing stricter anti-corruption measures.
The Ganguly-Chappell Feud
One of the most publicized disputes in Indian cricket history involved former captain Sourav Ganguly and coach Greg Chappell during 2005-06. Their conflict created a significant internal crisis within the BCCI, dividing players and fans alike.
The situation escalated when an email from Chappell questioning Ganguly's fitness was leaked, resulting in Ganguly's exclusion from the team and widespread protests. He eventually returned to the national squad after Chappell's departure, proving his worth through consistent domestic performances.
IPL 2013 Match-Fixing Scandal
Thirteen years later, another match-fixing scandal emerged during the IPL 2013 season, involving Rajasthan Royals players S. Sreesanth, Ajit Chandila, and Ankit Chavan, along with team owner Raj Kundra. This incident led to life bans for those implicated.
The BCCI faced intense criticism for its inability to prevent corruption in the IPL, prompting the establishment of the Lodha Committee to recommend reforms aimed at enhancing transparency and governance.
The 2008 Sydney Test Controversy
The 2008 Sydney Test between India and Australia is remembered for its controversies, particularly the racial abuse allegations against Harbhajan Singh concerning Andrew Symonds. This incident sparked a diplomatic row and raised questions about the BCCI's handling of the situation.
Despite the ICC initially imposing a three-match ban on Harbhajan, it was later overturned on appeal, but the BCCI faced criticism for its management of the affair.
Lalit Modi's Suspension
In 2010, the IPL and BCCI were scrutinized following the suspension of former IPL chairman Lalit Modi over allegations of financial misconduct and governance issues. Modi's controversial tenure and subsequent legal battles highlighted significant flaws in the BCCI's administration.
In 2013, the BCCI banned Modi for life, exposing governance weaknesses and drawing severe criticism. Modi fled to London to evade prosecution, where he continues to face multiple legal challenges.
Conflict of Interest Issues
Another significant controversy involved former BCCI president N. Srinivasan, who owned the Chennai Super Kings while serving in his administrative role. This dual position raised serious concerns about impartiality and governance, especially during the IPL 2013 match-fixing scandal.
The matter escalated to the Supreme Court, resulting in Srinivasan being barred from holding any administrative position within the board.
Recent Tensions with Pakistan
The BCCI faced backlash after Team India refused to shake hands with Pakistan players during the Asia Cup 2025, protesting against a terror attack in Jammu and Kashmir. This led to a standoff with the Pakistan Cricket Board.
Additionally, Team India declined to accept the Asia Cup trophy from the PCB and ACC chairman, Mohsin Naqvi, prompting the BCCI to threaten a formal protest to the ICC. Eventually, both parties reached an amicable resolution.
Lucknow T20I Match Abandonment
The most recent controversy arose when the fourth T20I match between India and South Africa was canceled due to poor air quality and fog at the Ekana Cricket Stadium in Lucknow. This decision followed multiple inspections by officials and led to significant backlash from fans regarding the BCCI's scheduling practices in North India during winter.
BCCI vice-president Rajeev Shukla acknowledged the need to reassess match scheduling in North India between December 15 and January 15 to avoid similar weather-related disruptions in the future.