Ashoke Pandit Critiques Naseeruddin Shah's Political Commentary: A Call for Reflection?

Filmmaker's Strong Words for Veteran Actor

Mumbai: Filmmaker Ashoke Pandit has publicly criticized veteran actor Naseeruddin Shah following Shah's recent comments about the government, suggesting that the actor's behavior has become erratic and may require professional help.

In response to a video where Shah donned a badge stating 'Dimagi Naxal' while expressing his discontent with the government, Pandit questioned Shah's choice of words, demeanor, and political stance.

During an exclusive interview, Pandit remarked, 'I am neither surprised nor shocked, as Naseeruddin Shah has been consistently abusive for over a year. His manners have deteriorated, and he now behaves like a ruffian. His way of addressing people, including the Prime Minister, is unacceptable.'

He continued, 'His behavior has spiraled out of control. Even thugs don't act this way, and he is supposed to be an educated individual. I question his education because his mannerisms and language reflect frustration.'

Expressing his disappointment, Pandit stated, 'It seems like he has lost his mental balance. His expressions are filled with anger, which I can understand, given that he is upset about films he disapproves of succeeding.'

'He is disturbed by the success of films like 'Kerala Story', 'Kashmir Files', and 'Dhurandar'. This insecurity stems from the changing landscape of cinema, which has left his traditional views behind.'

Pandit added, 'The shift in public perception, especially since Narendra Modi's leadership, has made him feel threatened. Mr. Naseeruddin Shah, you are part of a divisive group, and I am stating this directly to you. You have been verbally attacking many, including Anupam Kher, Shah Rukh Khan, and Amitabh Bachchan.'

'You seem to think you are infallible, which indicates a psychological issue. Please seek help; it could benefit you. Otherwise, your situation may worsen.'

Pandit expressed that he initially refrained from commenting but felt compelled as Shah's remarks crossed a line. 'Your criticisms of a political party are one-sided,' he noted.

Regarding the Bengal elections, Pandit challenged Shah's claims about BJP's victory, asking, 'Have you ever condemned the genocide of Hindus in Bengal? You must be aware of it, yet you remain silent.'

He emphasized, 'The migration of Hindus to Assam due to persecution is a significant issue. People are exhausted from the oppressive and anti-Hindu policies of the Mamata government, which is why BJP gained support.'

'Temples were restricted, and the government was openly anti-Hindu and anti-India. This is why the people voted them out. I urge you to seek treatment if you are using any substances; it could help you recover.'

For context, Pandit's comments followed Shah's social media video where he criticized the government's handling of student protests, using terms like 'anti-national' and 'tukde-tukde gang' while discussing democracy and student rights.

In the video, Shah drew comparisons to past protests at Jawaharlal Nehru University and referenced ongoing demonstrations at Jamia Millia Islamia, sparking renewed political discourse.