Naman Dhir's Controversial Catch Stirs Debate in India vs West Indies ODI

In a gripping second ODI match, Naman Dhir's remarkable diving catch to dismiss Keacy Carty has ignited a debate over the third umpire's decision. Initially ruled not out, the catch was later confirmed, leading to mixed reactions from fans on social media. As India leads the series 1-0, the West Indies aim to bounce back in the final match. This incident highlights the ongoing discussions around technology and decision-making in cricket.

By Narendra Chaudhary Sep 30, 2026, 16:55 IST

Dramatic Catch in the Second ODI

In a thrilling moment during the second ODI of the three-match series at Barsapara Cricket Stadium in Guwahati on September 30, Team India's all-rounder Naman Dhir executed a remarkable diving catch to dismiss West Indies opener Keacy Carty.

After winning the toss, Indian captain Shubman Gill chose to bowl first. The West Indies openers, John Campbell and Keacy Carty, started strong with a 37-run partnership before Prasidh Krishna claimed Carty's wicket, marking a significant breakthrough for India.

Key Partnerships and Milestones

Following Carty's dismissal, Campbell partnered with skipper Shai Hope, forming a vital 110-run partnership for the second wicket. Campbell eventually fell after scoring his second ODI century, amassing 101 runs off 68 balls, which included 9 fours and 5 sixes, at an impressive strike rate of 148.53.

Naman Dhir's Catch Under Scrutiny

Dhir's spectacular catch drew attention from fans and spectators alike. However, it was initially ruled not out by the umpire, leading to discussions about whether Dhir had successfully completed the catch.

The incident occurred in the fifth over when Carty edged a delivery from Prasidh Krishna towards cover. Dhir dove forward to secure a low catch, igniting excitement among his teammates while the West Indies anxiously awaited the replay to see if the ball had touched the ground.

Third Umpire's Decision

After reviewing multiple slow-motion angles, the third umpire confirmed that Dhir's fingers were indeed under the ball, leading to celebrations in the Indian camp as Carty was declared out for 9 runs off 10 balls.

Debate on Social Media

The catch has sparked a lively debate on social media platforms, particularly X (formerly Twitter), where fans expressed their opinions on whether the ball had touched the ground before Dhir secured it.

Many users questioned the third umpire's ruling, with some arguing that the ball appeared to make contact with the ground, while others were skeptical about Dhir's control during the catch. Comments ranged from 'Not Out' to calls for clearer replay angles.

India Leads the Series

Currently, Team India is ahead in the ODI series, having won the first match by 8 wickets at Greenfields International Stadium in Thiruvananthapuram. They aim to secure the series with another victory in Guwahati, while the West Indies seek to keep their hopes alive in the final ODI.