Concerns Arise Over Noise from Pickleball Courts in Marco Island

In Marco Island, Florida, the rise of pickleball has led to significant noise complaints from residents living near newly constructed courts. Rich Blonna, a local homeowner, has expressed his frustration over the disruption caused by the sport, which has replaced the tranquility of his neighborhood. While some players acknowledge the noise, they also highlight the sport's benefits. Blonna advocates for solutions to mitigate the noise impact, such as quieter equipment and sound barriers. As the popularity of pickleball grows, the community grapples with finding a balance between enjoying the sport and maintaining peace in residential areas.

By Narendra Chaudhary Mar 24, 2026, 16:23 IST

Noise Complaints from Local Residents

The growing popularity of pickleball has led to increased noise complaints in Marco Island, Florida. A local resident has voiced concerns regarding the construction of pickleball courts near his home, echoing similar issues seen in California. Residents are now seeking a balance between the sport's expansion and the tranquility of their neighborhoods.

Rich Blonna, who lives on San Marco Road, expressed frustration over the nine pickleball courts built at the YMCA Collier, which have disrupted the previously serene environment of his property. He noted that the courts are located just a few steps from his backyard, replacing the peaceful ambiance with persistent noise. “It’s like, poc, poc, poc. Nonstop,” Blonna remarked.

Initially, Blonna was informed that tennis courts would be constructed at the site, but plans shifted as pickleball gained traction. He has started measuring the noise levels with a decibel meter, which he claims recorded sounds in the 60 to 70 decibel range. “I can’t go into the hot tub or in the pool unless I put earplugs in,” he stated. “People on Marco Island have to wear ear protection just to sit outside.”

Some players at the facility acknowledged the noise issue but emphasized the sport's increasing popularity. “Sorry that we’re loud,” said Barbara Wagner. For many, pickleball has become a vital part of their daily routine. “It’s good competition, good exercise,” noted Dave Mustafaga, while Amber Mustafaga added, “We absolutely love it.” Wagner further commented, “It’s recreation, socialization, and friendship. It’s such a big part of my life now.”

Blonna clarified that he supports the sport but is advocating for measures to mitigate the noise impact in residential areas. He proposed solutions such as using quieter paddles and balls, as well as installing sound barriers. “I believe in healthy exercise. I think it’s wonderful. But this is a residential neighborhood. This isn’t downtown,” he explained.

The YMCA has indicated that it has taken preliminary steps, including planting bushes to help reduce the noise for nearby homes. A city meeting is set for April 20 to further discuss the matter, although officials have yet to comment on any potential resolutions.

As pickleball continues to grow in popularity worldwide, situations like the one in Marco Island underscore the challenges of balancing the sport's appeal with community concerns.