AJ Koller Aims for Full-Time Role in Upcoming MLP Draft

AJ Koller, known as the 'Super Sub' in Major League Pickleball, is determined to secure a full-time starting position in the upcoming MLP 2026 draft. After facing injuries and limited opportunities over the past two seasons, Koller is eager to showcase his skills and versatility. With several starting spots available, he hopes to find a team that values his experience and commitment to winning. As the draft approaches, Koller reflects on his journey and the challenges he has faced, making him a player to watch in the competitive pickleball landscape.

By Narendra Chaudhary Feb 26, 2026, 14:57 IST

AJ Koller’s Journey in Major League Pickleball

AJ Koller has faced numerous challenges during his two-season tenure in Major League Pickleball (MLP), earning the nickname “Super Sub” due to his limited playing time and resilience. As the MLP 2026 draft approaches on February 27, Koller is eager to secure a permanent starting position after spending two years primarily as a substitute. With at least 12 starting spots expected to open up due to team changes, Koller’s adaptability and experience could work in his favor, although it remains uncertain if any team will choose to sign him.

Expressing his aspirations for the upcoming season, Koller stated, "I enjoy meeting new ownership groups and players, but my goal is to contribute as a starter. I believe I possess a well-rounded game and am not lacking in any specific skills. I have defeated every top 20 player globally, and with a consistent partner, I am confident we can achieve great results," he shared with a media outlet.

His 2024 season was marred by a hamstring injury sustained while working out, which led him to miss several tournaments. Consequently, he went undrafted that year. For the past two seasons, Koller has participated in drafts as a waiver-wire asset and substitute. According to UPA contract guidelines, undrafted players can earn event credits by stepping in as substitutes during MLP events. He initially joined the AZ Drive in 2024 to fill in for a suspended player and later substituted for an injured player on the LA Mad Drops.

Adjusting to established teams midseason has been a challenge for Koller. He noted, "The best teams have a solid strategy, and it takes time to gel with new partners. I focus on the basics initially, and as I become more comfortable, we start to click. Partnering with Hunter Johnson towards the end of 2024 was a learning curve, but we managed to win our last five matches together."

Despite showcasing his versatility, Koller was again undrafted in 2025. He speculated that team-building strategies influenced this outcome. "In team sports, finding the right fit is crucial. My ideal fit is with a team focused on winning now," he explained. He observed that some teams prioritize social media presence or are looking to develop younger talent for future success.

At 36, Koller feels his age may have been a disadvantage in the draft process. In 2025, he continued as a substitute, briefly returning to the LA Mad Drops and NY Hustlers before securing a longer role with Brooklyn after an injury to another player. With Brooklyn, he partnered with Riley Newman in men’s doubles and achieved a 7-7 record, while excelling in mixed doubles with Rachel Rohrabacher, finishing with a 10-4 record as the team placed fourth in the regular season.

Koller praised Brooklyn's supportive environment, stating, "The ownership genuinely cares about winning and takes good care of the players, including team dinners and hotel arrangements. I hope to remain with a team like this." However, when the injured player returned for the playoffs, league rules mandated that he reclaim his starting position, leading to Brooklyn's defeat in two matches against the LA Mad Drops.

As the pickleball community anticipates the MLP 2026 draft, all eyes will be on Koller and his quest for a full-time role.