WWE SmackDown's Controversial Booking Decisions Leave Fans Confused

The latest WWE SmackDown episode has left fans scratching their heads over questionable booking decisions. Tiffany Stratton's unexpected loss, Jelly Roll's forced celebrity role, and Randy Orton's failed heel turn have all contributed to the confusion. As the wrestling community reacts, many are left wondering about the future direction of their favorite wrestlers. Dive into the details of this controversial episode and see what fans are saying about these puzzling choices.

By Narendra Chaudhary Mar 28, 2026, 14:27 IST

WWE SmackDown's Latest Episode Sparks Debate

The recent episode of WWE SmackDown in Pittsburgh has stirred discussions among fans due to some perplexing booking decisions. Notable moments included Tiffany Stratton's unexpected defeat, Jelly Roll's seemingly out-of-place motivational speeches, and Randy Orton's unsuccessful attempt at a heel turn.

Tiffany Stratton's Surprising Loss

Last week, Tiffany Stratton triumphed over Kiana James, setting the stage for a potential Women’s United States Championship match against Giulia. However, in a surprising twist, she faced Giulia in a non-title match instead. A brief distraction from James allowed Giulia to claim victory, leaving fans questioning the logic behind this booking choice.

For a former WWE Women’s Champion who was pivotal in 2025, this loss seemed to undermine her momentum. Many believe a disqualification or alternative finish could have better protected Stratton's standing, raising concerns about the direction of her character.

Celebrity Involvement: Jelly Roll's Role

While celebrity appearances can enhance WWE events, Jelly Roll's involvement on SmackDown is starting to feel contrived. He congratulated R-Truth and Damian Priest, and offered encouragement to Rhea Ripley before her match against Jade Cargill. However, Ripley, a seasoned competitor with seven consecutive WrestleMania title matches, hardly needs such motivation.

Although Jelly Roll's personal redemption arc is commendable, his attempts to uplift established champions seem unnecessary. Instead of enhancing the talent, these interactions appear to be WWE's way of trying to infuse star power into performers who already possess significant credibility.

Randy Orton's Heel Turn Fails to Resonate

Randy Orton's betrayal of Cody Rhodes provided fresh material for his storyline, but the expectation for fans to boo him has not materialized. As a cherished veteran, Orton continues to receive cheers, regardless of his actions. Even after delivering an RKO to Jelly Roll, the audience remained supportive.

When Matt Cardona confronted Orton, the crowd still chanted for The Legend Killer. WWE's efforts to portray Orton as a despised heel are faltering, as his legacy overshadows the intended narrative. This disconnect between booking and audience reaction underscores the challenges of transforming a long-time fan favorite into a villain.