What Does Amit Shah's UCC Announcement Mean for India's Political Landscape?
Opposition Voices Concerns Over UCC Implementation
New Delhi: On Monday, opposition parties criticized Home Minister Amit Shah's statement regarding the introduction of the Uniform Civil Code (UCC) in all states governed by the NDA before the 2029 general elections. They accused the BJP of leveraging this issue for communal and majoritarian purposes, with some dissent even emerging from its ally, JD(U).
Parties such as the DMK, CPI(M), and AIMIM expressed their opposition to the proposed UCC, while Sanjay Jha, the working president of JD(U), mentioned that party leaders would soon meet with Shah to discuss the UCC's implications in their state.
During a press conference in Mumbai on Sunday, Shah stated, "The abolition of triple talaq has granted Muslim women equal rights. We have already implemented UCC in several states, and I am confident that we will introduce it in all 21 BJP-NDA-ruled states before 2029."
Jha confirmed that they would engage with Shah regarding his comments on the UCC.
With 12 Lok Sabha MPs, JD(U) plays a crucial role in the BJP-led National Democratic Alliance (NDA) that supports the Modi administration.
The party, led by Nitish Kumar, also shares power with the BJP in Bihar.
In response to Shah's UCC announcement, CPI(M) argued that uniformity does not equate to equality, suggesting that the BJP's intentions are politically motivated as the next Lok Sabha election approaches.
"Shah's declaration that the UCC will be enforced across all 21 NDA-ruled states before 2029 makes the political agenda clear. This is not about women's rights; the BJP is manipulating a complex issue of equal rights to solidify its Hindutva voter base ahead of the elections," the party stated on social media.
The Left party accused the BJP of diverting attention from pressing issues like unemployment and inflation.
"Instead of addressing critical matters such as joblessness, rising prices, agrarian distress, and student issues, the BJP's focus is on orchestrating another divisive campaign," they claimed.
CPI(M) vowed to oppose the UCC and resist it at every turn.
DMK leader T K S Elangovan criticized Shah's assertion regarding UCC implementation, labeling it as unconstitutional.
Elangovan argued that enforcing the UCC in BJP-led states infringes upon the fundamental rights enshrined in the Constitution.
"This contradicts the Constitution of India. They cannot impose it because Article 25 guarantees every Indian the right to follow, preach, and practice any religion.
"What Amit Shah proposes is against the Constitution. This is fundamentally wrong," he asserted.
AIMIM president Asaduddin Owaisi strongly opposed Shah's remarks, alleging that the BJP aims to target Muslims.
"The UCC is not being introduced for equality. The BJP is implementing it in states where it governs solely to target India's 180 million Muslims.
"This violates Article 25, which ensures freedom of religion, Article 14, which guarantees equality, and Articles 26 and 29 of the Constitution," Owaisi stated.
He remarked that those unable to prevent the alleged theft at the Ram temple in Ayodhya are now discussing the UCC and NRC.
Owaisi emphasized that the essence of the nation lies in its pluralism, asserting that a UCC would impose Hindu law on non-Hindus.
Senior JD(U) leader and former minister Shyam Rajak reiterated the party's opposition to UCC implementation in Bihar, despite having supported the UCC Bill in Parliament.
"Our position was clearly articulated by our leader Nitish Kumar long ago. He stated that while our party supports the UCC Bill in Parliament, we do not favor its implementation in Bihar," Rajak explained in Patna.
"Although the chief minister may belong to the BJP, the government operates with the assistance of allies... our stance is clear; the question of implementing UCC in Bihar does not arise," he added.
Uttarakhand became the first state in independent India to enact a comprehensive UCC, with the law set to take effect in January 2025. This legislation encompasses marriage, divorce, succession, and live-in relationships, among other areas.
States like Assam, Gujarat, Madhya Pradesh, and Goa have also enacted laws to implement the UCC. Maharashtra, Chhattisgarh, and West Bengal have established drafting committees to prepare for the legislation.
Maharashtra Chief Minister Devendra Fadnavis stated that the UCC will be implemented once the drafting committee submits its report. Tripura Chief Minister Manik Saha indicated that the BJP-ruled state is prepared to implement the UCC if directed by the Centre.
Meanwhile, the Vishva Hindu Parishad welcomed Shah's statement on the UCC, asserting that it would serve as a "milestone" in the fight against gender inequality and discrimination.