Significant Citizenship Ruling for Family in Silchar
Citizenship Status Updated for Family in Silchar
A file image of foreigners' tribunal PTI Image
Silchar, Nov 18: In a pivotal ruling regarding a long-standing citizenship issue, the Fourth Foreigners Tribunal in Silchar has determined that five members of a family from Saidpur village, located in the Katigorah constituency, are Indian citizens. This decision overturns a previous ruling that had classified them as foreigners. However, the family patriarch, Mohanlal Das, has been designated as a ‘Streamline Foreigner’.
The tribunal's updated ruling was issued by Member Ranjan Roy on November 6, following a thorough review of three cases – FT 4th/379/2017, FT 4th/380/2017, and FT 4th/113/2019 – as directed by the Gauhati High Court.
The family had previously contested the tribunal's earlier decisions in the High Court, which ordered a re-evaluation of their cases on September 16, 2022. During the new hearings, original documents were submitted, and evidence was gathered. Advocates Dharmananda Deb and Debasmita Som represented the family in this matter.
The cases involved Mohanlal Das, his late wife Pramila Das, and their four children: Pushpabala Das, Sumanbala Das, Sudhan Das (also known as Shridham Das), and Madhu Das.
Mohanlal asserted that he entered India on September 30, 1964, providing a Relief Eligibility Certificate, a land deed from 1967, and electoral rolls dating back to 1970. However, the tribunal did not accept the certificate as valid evidence and concluded that he arrived in India after 1966 but before 1970, thus classifying him as a ‘Streamline Foreigner’.
The citizenship claim for Pramila Das was substantiated through documents presented by her brother, Dilip Kumar Das, which included the 1966 electoral roll listing their father, Jamini Kanta Das. The tribunal acknowledged this evidence, confirming their father's presence in India prior to 1966, and subsequently recognized Pramila Das and their four children as Indian citizens.
Advocate Dharmananda Deb commented on the ruling, highlighting its importance. He noted that over 16 original documents, including electoral rolls, land records, and birth and death certificates dating back to 1964, were submitted to the tribunal.
“After enduring years of legal ambiguity, the tribunal has affirmed the citizenship of the family members based on original documentary evidence. This is a crucial development, especially considering the previous unfavorable rulings,” Deb stated.
However, he raised concerns regarding Mohanlal Das’s status, indicating that the 75-year-old would be deprived of voting rights for another decade due to his classification as a ‘Streamline Foreigner’. Deb also recognized the contributions of advocate Debasmita Som in advancing the cases.