Opposition Leaders Challenge Amit Shah's Remarks on English Language

Union Home Minister Amit Shah's recent comments about English speakers in India have ignited a wave of criticism from various Opposition leaders. Rahul Gandhi defended the language as a vital tool for empowerment, while others echoed concerns about the implications of Shah's remarks on India's linguistic diversity. The controversy arises amidst ongoing debates about language policies in education, particularly regarding the imposition of Hindi. This article delves into the reactions from political figures and the broader context of Shah's statements, highlighting the significance of language in shaping identity and opportunity in India.

By Narendra Chaudhary Jun 20, 2025, 17:46 IST

Criticism of Amit Shah's Comments

On Friday, various Opposition figures expressed their disapproval of Union Home Minister Amit Shah's statement suggesting that English speakers in India would soon feel embarrassed. Congress leader Rahul Gandhi emphasized that English serves as a 'bridge' rather than a barrier, asserting that it enhances job opportunities and boosts self-esteem. He accused the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) and its ideological counterpart, the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS), of wanting to prevent underprivileged children from learning English, as it would empower them to question authority and strive for equality.

Gandhi further stated that in today's global landscape, mastering English is as crucial as learning one's native language.

Similarly, Dravida Munnetra Kazhagam MP Kanimozhi responded to Shah, stating that the real shame lies in imposing one's views on the populace and undermining India's diversity.

Kerala's Education Minister and Communist Party of India (Marxist) leader V Sivankutty remarked that no language holds superiority over another. He noted that English, as a global language, is vital for knowledge and communication, contributing positively to national progress.

Communist Party of India (Marxist) MP John Brittas criticized mainstream media for allegedly downplaying Shah's comments, suggesting that external pressures may have influenced this coverage.

Details of Shah's Statement

Shah’s Remarks

In a video circulated by various news channels on Thursday, Shah was reported to have claimed that a society where English speakers feel ashamed is on the horizon. He stated, 'A complete India cannot be envisioned with incomplete foreign languages; it can only be realized through Indianness and Indian languages.' This statement was made during a book launch event in New Delhi.

Shah referred to Indian languages as 'jewels of our culture,' asserting that without them, we lose our identity as Indians.

His comments come amid accusations from several state governments and regional parties that the central government is imposing Hindi through the National Education Policy's three-language formula.

Recently, the Maharashtra government mandated Hindi as a 'generally' taught third language for students in Marathi and English medium schools from Class 1 to Class 5. The Opposition has criticized this move as an attempt to dilute Marathi identity.

Tamil Nadu has also consistently opposed the three-language formula, reaffirming its commitment to a long-standing two-language policy that includes Tamil and English.