Manika Batra Demands Clarity on Asian Games Selection Process

Indian table tennis star Manika Batra has voiced her concerns regarding her exclusion from the Asian Games squad, demanding transparency and clear reasons for the decision. With a career spanning two decades, she questions the selection criteria, particularly regarding rankings and recent performances. Batra emphasizes the need for clarity in the selection process, not just for herself but for all athletes. Her call for accountability highlights the challenges faced by international players balancing global commitments with domestic tournaments. As the Asian Games approach, her statements raise significant questions about the fairness of the selection process.

By Narendra Chaudhary Jun 24, 2026, 11:46 IST

Concerns Over Exclusion from Asian Games Squad

Manika Batra, a prominent figure in Indian women's table tennis, has voiced her strong objections regarding her omission from the main team for the upcoming Asian Games. Instead of seeking a spot on the team, she is calling for transparency and clear explanations regarding the decision. The 31-year-old Olympian was placed on the reserve list when the Table Tennis Federation of India (TTFI) revealed its 10-member squad for the Aichi-Nagoya Asian Games.

'Not Seeking Selection, Just Answers'

Following her exclusion, Manika issued a comprehensive statement expressing her frustration. She emphasized her two-decade-long commitment to representing India at elite levels, acknowledging both triumphs and challenges. However, she criticized the lack of clarity in the selection process. "I am not asking to be selected or for anyone to reverse the decision. I simply want answers. No specific reasons for my exclusion have been communicated to me," she stated.

Questions on Ranking and Selection Criteria

Manika raised concerns about the criteria used for her selection, particularly regarding the ranking system. As the current World No. 51, she questioned the timeline considered during the evaluation. "Rankings in table tennis are updated weekly, which raises important questions. What period was used for assessment? Was it based on the last 12 months, six months, or just a single week's ranking?" she asked.

She also highlighted that recent performances against top international players should factor into selection decisions. "If an athlete fluctuates slightly in rankings, does that make her ineligible? My recent performances have been strong, including victories over top Asian and Chinese players. Current form should be a key consideration in evaluations, as emphasized by the Ministry of Youth Affairs and Sports for the Asian Games selection," Batra added.

Balancing International and Domestic Commitments

Manika pointed out the difficulties faced by athletes who compete internationally while also fulfilling domestic obligations. "While I respect national tournaments, athletes on the international circuit must juggle a demanding schedule, recovery, travel, and preparation for major events. Domestic participation should not be viewed separately from international commitments," she explained.

Concerns About Selection Process and Other Exclusions

She expressed surprise at the exclusion of other accomplished players, stating, "Athletes who have previously delivered medals for India deserve clarity on how these decisions were made. For instance, Ayhika Mukherjee, who contributed to India's historic women's doubles medal at the last Asian Games, raises questions about the selection criteria."

Issues with Voting in Selection Process

Manika also raised concerns regarding the selection process, mentioning that it involved a voting system. "If true, athletes should know who made these decisions and the rationale behind them. Were the reasons documented and communicated? Were there any conflicts of interest?" she questioned.

She further inquired about the safeguards in a voting-based system and the qualifications of the selectors. "Can a voting system be entirely free from bias? What measures ensure fairness? Athletes deserve to know the credentials of those making these decisions, including their experience in international competitions," she stated.

A Call for Transparency

In conclusion, Manika reiterated her demand for transparency, stating, "This is not about seeking a place on the team or special treatment. Every athlete deserves clarity and accountability in the selection process. After nearly twenty years of representing India, all I seek is a fair explanation. I am asking questions, not for special consideration."

Background on Asian Games Table Tennis

Batra is one of India's most celebrated table tennis players, having played a pivotal role in the country's success at the Asian Games. Alongside Sharath Kamal, she secured a mixed doubles bronze at the Jakarta 2018 Asian Games.

India's other table tennis achievements at the continental event include a men's team bronze in 2018 and a women's doubles bronze by Sutirtha Mukherjee and Ayhika Mukherjee at Hangzhou 2023.

The table tennis events at the Aichi-Nagoya Asian Games are set to occur from September 20 to 28.