Historic Shift in Eid Celebrations in West Bengal: A New Era of Order

This year, Eid in West Bengal unfolded in a manner that had not been witnessed in decades. For the first time since 1978, no prayers were held on the streets across the state. Kolkata's iconic Red Road, which has been a focal point for Eid prayers for millions, was notably empty, with traffic flowing freely. The largest Eid congregation in Kolkata was relocated from Red Road to Brigade Parade Ground this year. Historically, Red Road has symbolized Eid prayers in Kolkata, attracting vast crowds from Eastern India. However, the administration had previously indicated that religious events would not take precedence over law and public convenience. The Kolkata Police held multiple discussions with the Calcutta Khilafat Committee, ultimately designating Brigade Parade Ground as the new venue. Police officials confirmed that the ground falls under military jurisdiction and the necessary permissions for the event were secured. Consequently, prayers were conducted peacefully at this location, while Red Road remained clear of traffic for the first time during Eid.

Muslims attending the prayers expressed to the media that while Mamata Banerjee used to engage in politics at Red Road, the arrangements at Brigade were commendable, making the prayer experience enjoyable. Some attendees even called for support for the BJP in the upcoming elections, expressing pride in their Indian identity and commitment to upholding the law.

It is important to note that the government, led by Suvendu Adhikari, had issued clear directives prohibiting prayers on the streets, mandating that loudspeakers should not project sound beyond religious premises, and ensuring that roads remain unobstructed. This decision emerged amidst ongoing discussions about the inconveniences faced by citizens, traffic disruptions, and public disturbances.

Historically, this Eid congregation was initially held at Shahid Minar Ground. After flooding in 1919, it was moved to Red Road, which has since remained the center for this grand religious event, with interruptions only during the COVID-19 pandemic. Now, history has taken a new turn as the city embraces this new arrangement.

This entire episode conveys a clear message: while it is essential to respect religious beliefs in a democracy, maintaining law and order and ensuring public convenience are equally crucial. This year's Eid in West Bengal transcended mere religious observance, emerging as a new example of administrative discipline and public order. For the first time in decades, roads were not congested, traffic remained normal, and the religious event was conducted peacefully. This balance has been a long-standing demand.