Amanda Seyfried's Oscar-Worthy Performances in 2025: A Deep Dive

Amanda Seyfried has captivated audiences with her performances in 2025, particularly in 'The Housemaid' and 'The Testament of Ann Lee'. Despite critical acclaim and nominations from prestigious awards, she was overlooked by the Oscars. This article explores the depth of her roles, the unique storytelling of 'The Testament of Ann Lee', and the challenges faced by unconventional films in gaining recognition. Delve into Seyfried's portrayal of a woman deeply committed to her faith and the historical context of the Shaker community.

By Narendra Chaudhary Apr 6, 2026, 10:01 IST

Amanda Seyfried's Standout Roles in 2025

Amanda Seyfried has delivered two of the most captivating performances of 2025, one of which has sparked discussions about significant Oscar omissions.

In the thriller The Housemaid, Seyfried's performance was striking, even outshining her co-star Sydney Sweeney, which is no small feat. Additionally, her role in The Testament of Ann Lee is integral to the film's narrative. Despite receiving nominations from the Golden Globes and Critics’ Choice awards, the Oscars overlooked her talent.

The film's unconventional nature may have contributed to this oversight. Directed by Mona Fastvold, The Testament of Ann Lee delves into the life of the founder of the Shaker religious sect, a topic that the Academy often finds challenging to embrace. The film, available on JioHotstar, does not conform to the typical Oscar-friendly narrative.

Co-written by Fastvold and her partner Brady Corbet, who also worked together on The Brutalist in 2024, this biopic examines the fervent spirituality that inspired Ann Lee to establish the Shakers. Set in 18th-century England, the story follows Ann (played by Seyfried) and her brother William (Lewis Pullman) as they initially adhere to the Quaker faith, participating in ecstatic rituals known as shaking.

Ann's convictions evolve dramatically after her marriage to Abraham (Christopher Abbot). Following the tragic loss of her children shortly after birth, her aversion to sexual relations, and her pursuit of a more profound worship experience, she ultimately establishes the Shakers, earning the title Mother Ann, a female Messiah.

The narrative chronicles Ann's efforts to expand her community amid skepticism towards the Shakers' practices. After relocating from England to New England, she encounters both success and violent opposition.

Mona Fastvold's portrayal of this nearly extinct sect is marked by mysticism, intrigue, and reverence. While the Shakers' rituals may seem odd to modern audiences, the film remains faithful to Ann Lee's beliefs and the fervor of her followers. Even in moments that may appear irrational, Ann embodies dignity.

Filmed on 35mm, the movie boasts a rich visual quality that enhances the immersive performances of its cast, particularly Seyfried's powerful portrayal.

Amanda Seyfried shines as Ann Lee, skillfully depicting a woman who endures profound suffering due to her commitment to chastity and the intensity of her faith. Lewis Pullman also delivers a memorable performance as Ann's brother, who similarly forsakes his desires to accompany Ann on a path that is both unsettling and deeply significant for its followers.