×

Exploring the Complex Themes of 'Sarzameen': A Unique Take on Kashmir's Turmoil

The film 'Sarzameen' attempts to differentiate itself from typical Kashmir narratives by exploring the connections between military culture, parenting, and trauma. Centered around Army officer Vijay and his strained relationship with his son Harman, the film raises questions about identity and loyalty amidst conflict. With a plot twist that challenges Vijay's reputation, the film blends themes of personal sacrifice and dysfunctional family dynamics, leading to an unexpected comedic tone. Available on JioHotstar, 'Sarzameen' offers a fresh perspective on the complexities of life in Kashmir.
 

A Different Perspective on Kashmir

The film Sarzameen attempts to set itself apart from the typical narratives surrounding Kashmir, particularly those focusing on military operations against terrorism. It draws a connection between the strict military ethos, inadequate parenting, and the resulting trauma in children. Directed by Kazoye Irani and penned by Soumil Shukla and Arun Singh, the film positions itself as a bold and unconventional story.

However…

In the film, Army officer Vijay, portrayed by Prithviraj Sukumaran, is on the trail of a mysterious fugitive named Mohsin, whom he suspects to be the terrorist Qaabil (KC Shankar). Meanwhile, Vijay's relationship with his wife Meher (Kajol) is strained due to his harsh treatment of their son Harman (Ronav Parihar), who struggles with a stutter. Despite Meher's pleas, Vijay dismisses Harman as weak and unworthy.

When Qaabil abducts Harman, Vijay refuses to engage in negotiations. Years later, Harman returns, transformed with a muscular physique and confident demeanor, raising the question: is he truly Harman or a terrorist infiltrator?

Sarzameen is available on JioHotstar. The film's premise echoes Ramesh Sippy’s classic Shakti (1982), which tells the story of a principled police officer who allows kidnappers to take his son rather than compromise his duty. However, Shakti delves into the complex emotions of a son harboring resentment towards his father, a theme that does not seamlessly translate into a narrative about political insurgency.

As if the connections between Vijay’s choices and Harman’s evolution weren’t convoluted enough, Sarzameen features one of the most absurd plot twists in recent cinema. This revelation undermines Vijay’s esteemed reputation as a decorated officer, raising questions about the effectiveness of Army intelligence.

The blend of parenting lessons, the pursuit of terrorists, and personal sacrifice primarily resonates with the characters played by Prithviraj Sukumaran and Kajol. Other cast members, such as Jitendra Joshi as the well-meaning Muslim character and Mihir Ahuja as Qaabil’s associate, barely leave an impression.

Ibrahim Ali Khan struggles to convey the emotional turmoil and anger of Harman. Any hint of psychological complexity is quickly overshadowed by a melodramatic portrayal of a dysfunctional family, which inadvertently veers into comedic territory.